Jalapeno Pimento Cheese (5 Minutes)

Jalapeño pimento cheese is sharp cheddar, cream cheese, mayo, diced pimentos, and chopped pickled jalapeños mixed together into a bold, creamy spread. Hand-shred the cheddar — no exceptions — and make sure the cream cheese is fully at room temperature before you start. It comes together in 5 minutes and disappears just as fast.

This one comes up everywhere in my kitchen. It goes on burgers, into sandwiches, stuffed into poppers, or eaten straight off a cracker at the counter. I’ve made it more times than I can count, and the pickled jalapeño version is the only one I bother with anymore.

Key Ingredients

• Sharp cheddar, 1 pound: Sharp is the move. Mild cheddar gets lost behind the mayo and cream cheese. Grate it yourself on the large holes of a box grater.
• Cream cheese, 8 oz: Full fat, room temperature. This is the base that holds everything together.
• Duke’s mayo, 1/2 cup: Duke’s is the standard for a reason. Full fat, no sweeteners, tangy. Use whatever full-fat mayo you have but don’t sub in light mayo.
• Pickled jalapeños, 1/4 cup chopped: Make your own if you can. Store-bought canned works too. Chop them so you get a little heat in every bite rather than one big chunk.
• Diced pimentos, 4 oz drained: One small jar, drained well. They add sweetness and color without competing with the jalapeños.
• Smoked paprika: Just 1/2 teaspoon, but it adds a subtle smokiness that ties the whole thing to the grill. Regular paprika works if that’s what you have.
• Ground mustard: Tangy and aromatic. Pairs well with sharp cheddar and cuts through the fat.

How to Make Jalapeño Pimento Cheese

Step 1: Soften the cream cheese

Put your room-temperature cream cheese in a medium bowl and beat it with a wooden spoon until it’s completely smooth. No shortcuts here. Lumps at this stage mean lumps in the final dip, and they don’t mix out later.

Step 2: Add the mayo and spices

Add the mayo and mix until fully blended with the cream cheese. Then add the smoked paprika, ground mustard, kosher salt, sugar, and black pepper. Stir to combine. Taste it. The base should be tangy, slightly smoky, and well-seasoned before the cheese goes in.

Step 3: Fold in the cheddar

Add the shredded cheddar in batches, stirring each addition fully into the mix before adding more. Room temperature cheddar incorporates much cleaner than cold. If you’re using a stand mixer, use the paddle attachment on low.

Step 4: Fold in the peppers

Add the drained pimentos and chopped pickled jalapeños last. Fold gently. You want pieces of pepper in every bite, not pulverized into the mix. Taste and adjust salt if needed.

Step 5: Rest and serve

You can eat it immediately at room temperature, which is how it’s best served. Cover and refrigerate if making ahead. Pull it out of the fridge 20 to 30 minutes before serving so it softens up. It stays fresh for about 3 days covered in the fridge.

Ways to Use Jalapeño Pimento Cheese

• Smoked Burgers: Melt a scoop over the patty in the last two minutes of the cook. It holds together better than sliced cheese and covers every inch of the burger.
• Jalapeno Poppers: Fill the jalapenos with this mix, wrap in bacon, and smoke. HUGE hit!
• Bacon-Wrapped Sausage Popper Boats: Stuff them with this instead of plain cream cheese. The jalapeño and cheddar flavors are already there — this makes them louder.
• Honey Pepper Pimento Chicken Sandwich: The combo of grilled chicken, hot honey, and a dollop of this cheese mix is pure heaven.
• Smoked Meatballs: Try stuffing each meatball with a little bit of this mix for an extra pop.

Frequently Asked Questions

Equipment

• Box grater: Large holes for the cheddar. Non-negotiable.
• Medium mixing bowl: Large enough to fold in a pound of cheese without spilling.
• Wooden spoon: For beating the cream cheese and folding. A rubber spatula works too.
• Stand mixer with paddle attachment (optional): For a creamier, more uniform result.

Print